Sand
It's taken 2 months, but Josiah has finally realized that there is actually nothing to stop him from putting Daniel's pacifiers in his mouth. And with that realization, the oral fixation that I thought we so easily got rid of with a new green bike, is back.
And while we do punish (or at least threaten to punish, which I suppose is part of the problem) him for sucking on Daniel's pacifiers, there is nothing on the front end to stop the actual act. Just a consequence afterwards. Which, unfortunately, is not always a deterrent for a 3-year-old.
But it isn't just the pacifiers. Because he does know that he is not supposed to play with them or suck on them. It's everything. Fingers, toys, money... everything is back in his mouth.
Of course Daniel doesn't care. He would actually much rather suck on his fingers. He just can't seem to find them all the time. So this morning at 5am when he didn't want to nurse and he didn't want the pacifier and I had changed his diaper and still he continued to fuss... I stuck his fist in his mouth and he was happy. And he eventually isolated his thumb and sucked away until he fell back asleep.
I'm torn. I like the idea of not having to worry about dropping pacifiers into the Hong Kong Harbor. Or loosing them on the bus. Or putting them back in little mouths in the middle of the night. But you can't very well trade a thumb for a bike at 3-years-old. I'll keep giving him the pacifier and as he develops more muscle control, I guess we'll see which one he chooses.
well crafted post, my dear! i kept waiting for the sand to show up.
ReplyDeletethat's a complicated decision... i feel like parenting seems a LOT easier from the outside. I was thinking thumbs were better but then I remembered that I was a horribly incorrigible thumb and finger sucker until much too late, and my teeth were totally messed up as a result. maybe pacifiers?
Josh was a thumb sucker and his parents DID get him a bike as a reward for stopping! :-) so it may still work. :-D
ReplyDeleteWell...... well.... I don't know!!! We didn't let Aria regularly use a pacifier for the first few months (except during diaper changes). We went with the blanket route. And by the time she was 6 months old, she was like: "WHY ARE YOU STICKING THAT IN MY MOUTH?! I DON'T WANT IT!" Course... now she likes to drag her blankets around the house. But don't worry, she's not like Linus! She has several blankets that don't look the same, so they are all interchangeable. I still use/have my own baby blanket too... I'm going to be sad if I ever lose that thing.... ^o^
ReplyDelete